Chapter 32
Chapter 32
The trial took two days — which is what these things take when the paperwork is already written and the accused has already agreed with the paperwork.
It was not a courtroom like the ones on television. There was a raised bench and a panel of three. There was a prosecutor, a defense lawyer, a clerk with a laptop, and a small public gallery with a few chairs. There was no jury, because there is no jury. The whole thing was the size of a small classroom and smelled of floor cleaner and photocopier, and the walls were a government color. There was a clock, and the clock worked. Yiming watched it the way he had watched the clock in the hospital corridor in 2019 — which is to say he watched it move without believing that it moved for him.
There were no cameras, and no gallery for the press, and no crowd at the door. It was a Tuesday and a Wednesday in a building full of other Tuesdays and Wednesdays. Yiming sat on a plastic chair in a small room and listened to the state describe him, and outside the window a municipal truck went by and emptied the bins, and nobody in the room looked up. He had thought, in the cell, that the day would feel like the end of something. It felt like a form.
His mother came on the first day and sat in the second row in a dark shirt with her hands folded. She did not cry, because she did not cry. His father came too, in the good shirt from the year before the stabbing, because he had decided that this was a day that required it. He sat beside her with the bad arm in his lap and did not look at the panel once. He looked at his son the whole time — the way he had looked at him in the shop, hands first and face second. Ying was there on the first morning, and then not there. A few people from the market came, because the market came to everything. Mrs. Cheung came and sat at the back with her dried goods put away for once, and did not say the sentence to anyone, and did not need to.
His mother had brought a thermos she did not open. His father had brought nothing at all — the father had never in his life brought a thing to a place where the thing was not needed, and what he brought instead was the shirt, and the sitting, and the not-looking-away. Mrs. Cheung sat at the back with her hands folded and did not say the sentence, not once, not to anyone. When the clerk read the charge she closed her eyes for a moment and then opened them. That was the whole of what she did, and it was more than anyone else in the room understood.
The charges were read out. The killing of Mak Tak-ming — intentional, in a warehouse on the canal road, on the last night of the fifth month. The charge was guyi sharen (故意杀人). The prosecutor read it in the flat state voice that these things are read in, and the words came out of him the way water comes out of a tap. Yiming sat and listened to a man he had never met describe the last ten minutes of the summer in the language of the state.
Then the clerk asked him, and he answered.
The court went through it in order. The evidence of the killing was not in dispute; the driver’s video and the warehouse camera and the two men at the gate and the confession had settled it. The defense lawyer was a woman of about forty who had been assigned to him. She had come to the cell three times, and had asked him the same question each time — whether he wanted to plead self-defense, or provocation, or temporary incapacity — and each time he had told her no. He had told her that he had gone to the warehouse holding the pole of a man who could not lift, and had meant to do what he did. He had told her that a man who means a thing is not allowed to pretend afterward that he did not. She had looked at him for a long time, and then had written down what he said, in her own words, which were better than his.
So the defense did not argue the killing. The defense argued the surrender and the merit. It put before the panel the fact that the accused had walked into the paichusuo at dawn with the weapon and had not run — which is zishou (自首). And it put before the panel the paragraph in the file that listed what the surrender had produced: the room, the recruiter, the vans, the warehouse, the laminator man, the bought officer; the recovery of seven people and the return of one boy to his mother; the whole of a network that the province had been unable to move on until a cook walked into a police station with a stick and a name. The lawyer called it what the law calls it — zhongda ligong (重大立功). She read out the list with the flat patience of a woman reading a bill, and she read the boy’s return home last, and then she stopped, and the panel wrote.
The lawyer came the last time on the night before the verdict. She had a folder and a bag of oranges and the look of a woman who had done everything she could and knew it was not enough. She told him, in the careful voice she used for clients, what the range of outcomes was. She said the merit was strong, and the surrender was clean, and that she expected the suspended sentence. She said that life was the floor and death was the ceiling, and that the floor and the ceiling were further apart than people thought. Then he asked her the only question he had — whether the family of the dead man had been contacted, and whether they wanted anything. She said the family had declined to make a statement and had declined to attend, and that they had a lawyer and a number, and that they wanted what money can want. He told her to give them the number. She did not answer. After a while she stood and took her folder and went out. The oranges she left on the table. He ate one and gave the rest away, because there is no point keeping fruit in a place where nothing keeps.
On the second day they read the verdict and the sentence.
The panel read the reasoning first, which took forty minutes. It was the law the way the law is — intent, act, consequence, mitigation, cooperation, merit, and at the end a number. Yiming listened to the numbers being read. He did not understand all of them and did not need to. Across the room his mother’s hands were folded on the rail, and his father’s one good hand was flat on the bench beside her, and the two of them sat the way the family sat at the ledger, which was with their backs straight and their faces still.
The prosecutor asked for the death sentence and did not get it. The asking was not cruelty; it was the job. The defense asked for time served and a lesser charge and did not get that either. Yiming sat between the two of them and watched them weigh his life, and felt nothing he could name.
The charge was intentional homicide, with no lawful mitigation for the act itself, and with full surrender and major merit entered in the accused’s favor. The panel gave him sihuan (死缓) — the suspended death sentence, which is a death sentence that is not carried out, and which in practice, with the merit and the cooperation, would become life, and then would become a number of years that a man of his age could conceivably live through, and perhaps be released from, in a city he would not recognize. The clerk read the name when the papers were done, the way the clerk read every name. Yiming answered the way he had answered four hundred times in his life.
“Dou.”
Then they took him out, and the room folded up the way these rooms fold up.
He would think about the two days for years, and what he would remember was not the verdict, and not the charge, and not the prosecutor, and not the lawyer. What he would remember was the clock. The truck emptying the bins outside the window. The way the clerk’s voice changed slightly when he read the sentence. The thermos his mother had brought and never opened. The fact that his father had worn the shirt that hung wrong on the ruined shoulder for a day that lasted two days. A trial is supposed to be about the worst thing a person did. What it is actually about, he understood, is the ordinary details that the worst thing cannot erase — and the details are the only part that lasts. His mother stood up in the second row and did not reach for him, because there was glass and distance and an officer. His father stood up slowly with the bad arm. The two of them looked at him across the well of the small room and did not say anything. That was the last time Yiming saw his father standing in the open air, because the next time he saw him it would be through a pane of thick glass with a telephone in his hand, and the father would be sitting down.
He thought, walking down the corridor to the van, about the market, and about the print he had pasted on the door on the last night — the four-yuan god with the small bat in the corner. He thought about the fact that he had never once, in a year, decided to be Zhong Kui Gor. The city had decided it for him, the way the city decided everything, and now the city would decide what he was next — a number in a file, a line in the paper, a story the aunties told — and none of it would be him. He was going in as Li Yiming. He would come out, if he came out, as a man the street used to know. That was the whole of the sentence, and the panel had only written the number of years on the cover of it.
The van went through the streets he had grown up in, and he looked out at them through the little window, and they were already changing.
He would not see the street again for a long time. When he did, it would be a different street with the same name, and the shop would be under a tower, and his father would be dead, and none of that was the thing he was thinking about. He was thinking about the bowl his father had pulled that morning, and the two beats he would tap on the rail that night, and the ordinary arithmetic of a man being driven away from everything he had ever made. The market street was fenced. The arcade had a new sign. The canal road had a row of young trees where the hoarding had been, and the concrete where the blue wall had stood had been poured over and was smooth and gray and clean. He was glad. There was no one there to look at, and no one there to look back, and the city had already begun the long, indifferent work of turning the summer into a story it could live beside — which is what cities are for.
His mother did not come to the cell to say goodbye before the transfer. She had said it already, at the glass and at the courtroom, and there was nothing in the family that needed saying twice. But when the van pulled out of the gate she was standing on the pavement across the road with her hands folded, in the dark shirt. She did not wave, and he did not wave. The van took him away, and she stood there until it was out of sight, which was the last thing he saw of the free city.