IF THE WORLD IMITATES ME
☰

Chapter 22

The Copycat King

By the eleventh month, Lai San had a festival.

It was called the 山城济公文化节 — the Mountain City Ji Gong Cultural Festival — and it ran for three days on the riverside plaza below the tower, and it had a stage and a lighting rig and a drone show and a vegetarian food street and a “merit walk” and a “blessing of the waters” and a charity gala, and the title sponsor was the Foundation for Cultural Renewal, whose logo was on every banner, and the organizing company was Lai San’s, and the attendance, over three days, was estimated by the organizers at two hundred thousand people and by the police at eighty thousand and by the aunties, who had watched the whole thing on a phone at the tea-room table, at too many, and every one of them alone.

I went on the second day, because I had to see it, and because Huajiao said I had to see it, in the flat voice she used when she was making me do a thing for my own good, and because a man who has spent two years being a symbol should look, once, at what the symbol has become.

It was worse than I had imagined and better than I had feared and entirely, exactly, what I should have expected. There was a merchandise row: fans, gourds, robes, prayer beads, stickers, tote bags, a “merit candle” in a glass jar with a small electric flame, a children’s brand of “Little Ji Gong” clothing. There was a food street: congee (free), noodles (¥12), a “Ji Gong burger” (¥18), a “Buddha bowl” (¥32), a stall selling “healing tea” that was, I am fairly sure, oolong with sugar. There was a “compassion wall” where children wrote wishes on cards and hung them, and a “good-deed photo booth” where you could pose helping an old woman cross a painted street, and a donation box in the shape of a lotus that took cash and cards and phone payments and printed a receipt with a QR code that led to the foundation’s page. And on the stage, between acts, a succession of men in robes — some of them real monks from real temples, some of them Lai San’s employees — said things about the heart and the city and the importance of helping, and the crowd, which was enormous and ordinary and mostly poor, listened and clapped and filmed and ate.

I walked the whole of it with a paper bowl of congee in my hand and did not eat it. I have tried many times to describe what I felt and I have never managed it, and I think the reason is that the feeling was not one feeling. It was the feeling of a man watching his own face on a banner and knowing that the face was not his and also knowing that the face had been made out of him and that he had not been asked. It was the feeling of a man recognizing, in a crowd of eighty thousand, about eleven people who were doing it sincerely — the woman who ran the congee stall and had run it for two temples for thirty years; the old man who had come with his own fan and was walking the perimeter and bowing to no one; the child who had written I want my grandmother to walk again on a card and hung it, and had not been given a camera to do it for. And it was the feeling of a man understanding that the eleven sincere people were the reason the whole thing worked, because the machine needed them the way a fire needs oxygen, and that they were not victims and not accomplices and not fools, and that there was no word in the language for what they were.

I spent the middle of the day at the congee stall, because the congee stall was the only honest thing at the festival and I wanted to stand near it.

The woman who ran it was fifty-eight and her name was Auntie Xiu, and she had served congee at the temples of this city for twenty-nine years, through three rebuilds and one fire, and she did not know or care that she was at a branded festival. She had been hired by the organizers for four hundred yuan and all the congee she could serve, and she had accepted because four hundred yuan is four hundred yuan and because she had a grandson with a heart condition, and I did not learn that last part from her; I learned it from the woman beside her, who told me while Auntie Xiu was at the pot and could not hear. Auntie Xiu served every person in the line the same oversized ladle, and when the organizers came at noon and asked her to slow down because the free congee was running the merchandise numbers, she said, in the flat voice of a woman who had been doing this since before any of them were born, “The rice is cooked. The people are here. I am not slowing down.” And she did not slow down, and the organizers did not push it, because even in a counterfeit economy there is one thing you cannot stage, and it is a woman who has been making congee for twenty-nine years and has decided how much rice each stranger gets.

She is the reason I kept going back to the festival. Not for the myth. For the ladle. There is a whole religion in that ladle and it is not on any banner, and it was the only thing at the festival that the foundation could not license and the Society could not franchise and the feeds could not cut for a clip, because it took four seconds and had no reaction shot in it.

I met the old man with his own fan at the compassion wall, where the children hang their wishes on cards. He was about eighty and he had a real palm-leaf fan, cracked and mended with fishing line by his own hand, and he was not part of the festival; he was a retired stevedore who walked the river every day and had come to watch the crowd, the way old men in this city watch any crowd, which is to say with the deep unresolvable amusement of a man who has seen the water rise and fall for eighty years and does not expect anything new. He did not know who I was. That was the luxury of him. He looked at my gourd and my fan and my jacket and did not connect the three, because he had never watched the clips and did not own a phone, and when I asked him what he thought of the festival he said, “I think the dumplings are expensive and the congee is free, which is the same as every year of my life.” And then he told me about the flood of 1981, which I had heard from Uncle Tuo and had never heard from anyone else, and his version was better, because Uncle Tuo’s version had him carrying a table on his head and this man’s version had the table floating away and Uncle Tuo swimming after it, and I have never been able to decide which of them was lying, and I have decided that both of them were telling the truth they had chosen, which is how this city remembers anything.

The children’s wishes were the hardest. I read the wall twice. There were about four hundred cards, hung on strings in the shape of a heart, and most of them were the ordinary wishes of the ordinary poor: I want my grandmother to walk again. I want my mother to stop crying. I want to pass the exam. I want my father to come home from Guangdong. And then, among them, in a child’s hand, one card that said: I want to be the man in the yellow jacket. And below it, another, in a different hand, that said: I want to be the man who helps him. I stood in front of those two cards for a long time. I did not take them. I did not tell anyone. I have thought about them for years, and what I think is this: the first card is the whole problem of this book, and the second card is the whole solution, and the tragedy is that no one at the festival could tell the difference, because the foundation had printed both kinds of card and the string they hung on was in the shape of a heart, and the heart was sponsored.

By afternoon the crowd was sixty thousand and the merchandise row had sold out of the children’s brand and the drone crew was setting up on the embankment, and I walked the perimeter the way I walk the Trail, looking for the seam, because a crowd that size is a body and a body has seams, and I found the seams and I did not find the danger, because the danger was not in the crowd. The danger was in the eleven people who walked off the rope line after dark, and I have already told the reader about the one who did not come back.

And then, at dusk, on the second night, the thing happened that I had been afraid of since the spring.

The “merit walk” was a procession along the river rocks. The route went along the exposed shallows below the plaza, a stretch the river leaves bare in winter, and the point of it — the organizers’ point — was that walking the shallows was a hardship offering, a small pilgrimage, a way for ordinary people to do a difficult good thing in a line with strangers. It was supervised by volunteers with flashlights and a rope line. It was, by the standards of a city that builds footbridges over gorges, entirely safe.

And a boy of about twenty, at the tail of the procession, decided to do it properly.

I did not see him go. That is the first thing. I was forty meters away, at the top of the embankment, with the congee that I was not eating, and the fog was coming up off the water the way it had come up off the water in every scene of this book, and somewhere below me a boy in a robe that was not a robe stepped off the rope line and onto a rock he did not know, because the story had taught him that a man with a fan could walk into the water and come out clean.

The water at the shallows was not shallow. It was the edge of a river that had drowned my father’s city for a thousand years. He went in at the turn, where the current takes a man’s legs, and the volunteers’ flashlights swung and someone shouted, and the crowd — which was a crowd, with all the rules of a crowd — did what crowds do, which is to stop and film. And by the time I got down the embankment and into the water, the boy was already gone, and I was a man in a yellow jacket standing in the river in the dark with the fog around my chest and a hundred phone lights on the bank, and I did not find him. The river took eleven minutes to give him back. The rescue boats came. The police came. The organizers, to their credit, had had boats on station, because they had known, as every organizer knows, that a crowd and a river are a pair.

The boy’s name was 阿俊, A-Jun. He was twenty. He was a student. He had, on his phone, a photograph of the founder’s fan and a screensaver of the founder’s face, and he had come to the festival from a city two hours away, and he had, according to his roommate, spent the whole term talking about how he was going to “do something real.” His mother was a cleaner. His father sold insurance. They came to the festival the next morning and stood on the embankment where he had gone in, and the organizers gave them a hotel room and a wreath and a donation, and the foundation sent a representative, and the cameras came, and by the afternoon the boy was on every platform in the province, and the number under the video was climbing.

I have watched that number climb. I watched it because I could not look away, and because I needed to know what the city would do with a boy who drowned imitating a man, and the city did what it always does, which is to make the boy mean something. The first day, he was a martyr of compassion. The second day, he was a cautionary tale about the dangers of unregulated folk religion. The third day, he was a hashtag. By the fourth day, he was gone, and the festival had announced its attendance figures, and the merchandise had sold out, and Lai San’s company had signed a three-year contract with the district, and the foundation had pledged to build an aquatic-safety training center in the boy’s name, which was the most useful and least honest thing anyone did in the eleven days.

I found Lai San at the stage on the last night, in the golden hour, before the drone show.

He was alone, in a good coat, with a cup of the healing tea, watching the technician test the lights. He had gotten richer in the two months since the warehouse bay, and he had gotten, in the same period, quieter; the gold chain was gone, the jacket was better, and there was a thing behind his eyes that had not been there in the spring, which I recognized because I had seen it in the mirror, and which is the specific expression of a man who has discovered that he is not the head of the thing he built.

“You came,” he said, without looking at me.

“I came.”

“Good. You should see it. It’s better than the alley. It’s better than the cable car. It’s a city.” He gestured at the plaza with his cup. “Eighty thousand people came to do good deeds for three days because a drunk fell down in a lane. The temples sold the congee. The district got the tourism. The foundation got the tax deduction. The kids got a weekend. And one boy died, and I will carry that to my grave, and the reason I will carry it to my grave is not that I do not care. It is that I do not know what I could have done differently, because the walk had a rope and the rope had volunteers and the boy stepped off the rope, and a rope is a rule, and a rule is not a wall.”

“You sold him the fan.”

“No.” He said it without heat. “You sold him the fan. I retailed it. There is a difference, and the difference is the last two years, and you have never once been willing to look at it.” He turned and looked at me for the first time, and the satisfaction was there, and under the satisfaction was the tiredness, and under the tiredness was the thing I had seen on the edge of Tan Xiao’s stage, which is a man who has run out of a reason. “Let me tell you what I have become, because I think you deserve to hear it and because there is no one else in this city who would understand. I am the operations of a myth. The myth is yours. The myth was always yours. I am the man who puts the myth in boxes and ships it. And I am very good at it, and I am very rich, and I am going to get richer, and I am never going to be able to stand on a stage and say a true thing, because a true thing would end the business, and the business is now bigger than me, and if I stopped, someone else would pick it up by morning.” He drank his tea. “You wanted a saint. I gave the city a saint. The saint is a product. The product works. And the only person in this whole city who thinks that is wrong is the man who accidentally made the product, and the man who accidentally made the product is standing in front of me with a free bowl of congee that he has not eaten.”

I did not have an answer. I had a boat, and a river, and a boy’s screen saver, and eleven days of numbers, and no answer. And that, I think, was the last moment in the whole of that year in which I still believed that the thing could be stopped by a person saying the right sentence to another person. After that night, I stopped believing it. The festival went on. The drone show spelled 心 — heart — in the sky over the river, and the crowd filmed it, and the number went up, and a boy who had wanted to do something real became, for eleven days, a metric.

I went home the next morning and I did not sleep, and at about seven, as I was leaving for the Trail, there was a girl at the mouth of the tunnel with a plastic bag, and it was Amei, fifteen, Aguang’s sister, and she had come to give me something.

She had grown, in the way that children in this city grow, which is not much and too fast. She held the bag out and said, “My brother had these. I didn’t know they were his until the Society came. Then I knew. I don’t want them in the house.”

I opened the bag. It had a cardboard fan in it — a second one, a spare, the same as the one that had gone into the drain, made out of a piece of a dumpling box and packing tape, with the ribs drawn on in marker and the crack drawn on too. And it had a printout, a screenshot, of a video the boy had saved: the clip of me, in the alley, in the first winter, bowing to four men. He had watched it, evidently, many times; the file was named with a date and a heart. And it had a photograph, a real one, printed at a shop, of the two of them — Amei and Aguang — at a night market, eating skewers, laughing, with his arm around her. He had written something on the back in pen, and the writing was the rounded schoolboy hand I had seen on the guesthouse register at the edge of the map, and it said: 妹,等哥把钱还完,带你去坐长江索道。 — Little sister, when I finish paying off the money, I’ll take you on the Yangtze cableway.

I stood at the mouth of the tunnel with the bag in my hand, and Amei looked at me with her brother’s eyes and said, in a voice that was already the voice of a person who had stopped expecting adults to do anything:

“The Society wanted to put him on a flag. The man from the fan shop wanted to put him on a t-shirt. The foundation wanted to put him in a training center. Everybody wants a piece of him. I just want my brother.” She turned to go. Then she stopped. “He saved my life once. Not like in the videos. Our father left and he dropped out and he worked, and he kept the lights on, and nobody filmed it, and there’s no video. That’s the whole of him. That’s the thing they don’t want. It’s boring. It doesn’t make a good video.” She looked back at me. “Don’t let them do it to you. You’re the only one they can’t buy. That’s the only thing I know about you, and I know it from him.”

She walked off into the morning. I went to the temple and swept the courtyard, because it was the only thing in the city that still asked nothing of me but my arm and did not put my face on a banner, and Chen Popo watched me from her chair, and the arhats looked down with their mended faces, and on the far side of the courtyard a man in a wheelchair watered a row of empty pots with an empty can.