YOUNG RIVER
☰

Chapter 20

Chapter Twenty

Approval No. SUMC-EC-2021-047. Protocol: twenty-year follow-up of a child cohort, Guiyu, 2004–2006. Approved with conditions: re-consent of all adult participants; no bone densitometry outside the hospital; results returned individually. Valid from 1 March 2022. — ethics committee letter, Shantou University Medical College

The graduation was in June, in the hall with the red brick and the banyan trees, and his mother came up on the bus.

It was her first time in Guangzhou. She had been to Shantou twice in her life and to Chaoyang town perhaps twenty times, and she had never been four hundred kilometres from the lane. She came with a bag of food—a whole braised goose in a tin, cut in pieces. Wrapped in three layers of cloth—and she carried it on her lap for the entire four and a half hours because she did not trust the luggage hold.

At the gate she stopped and looked at it. Then she said, “It is very wide,” and that was all she said about the university.

He showed her the campus. She looked at the banyans and said the roots were like the roots of the old banyan at the temple. She looked at the lake and asked whether there were fish in it and whether anyone ate them. She looked at the library and asked how many books and did not believe the number.

The hall held a thousand and it was full. The gowns were black and the hoods were coloured by faculty, and the engineering faculty’s were orange, and there were four hundred of them in rows. And the air conditioning could not keep up with four hundred people in heavy cloth, so the whole hall smelled of hot polyester and breath.

His mother had put on the good blouse, the one with the small flowers, and had had her hair done at the salon on the market road for fifteen yuan. And she sat with her knees together and her handbag on her knees and did not put it on the floor.

The president spoke. A graduate spoke. Somebody’s parents in the row behind took photographs with a phone and the shutter sound was on and it went off eleven times.

When his name was read he walked across the stage, and the dean shook his hand and said a sentence he did not hear. And he took the certificate and turned and looked for the third row and did not find it. And then found it, and his mother’s face was doing something it did not usually do, and then it stopped doing it.

At the graduation she sat in the third row and did not take a photograph, because she did not have a camera. And she watched the whole ceremony with her hands folded in her lap and her lips slightly apart, the way she watched the fish man weigh a bream.

Afterwards, in the gown, he took her to the canteen and bought her a bowl of noodles, and she ate half of it and said it was too expensive. And then she asked whether he had eaten, and pushed the other half across the table.

She went back on the evening bus with the empty tin.

He moved to Shantou in September and rented a room on the fourth floor of a building behind the medical campus, six hundred yuan a month, with a window that looked at a wall.

The room had a bed, a desk, a chair, a wardrobe with one door that did not close, and a small balcony where the previous tenant had kept a plant that had died. He put the pencil on the desk, point-down, and the printout in the desk drawer, and the coin from his grandfather’s shoe in a bowl beside the lamp.

The bus home took two hours. He went on the first and the fifteenth, when he could, and his mother fed him and his father sat at the bench and did not talk. And Ah-Ma poured the three cups and asked about the university and did not listen carefully to the answers, because the answers were not the point.

The ethics application took eleven months.

He had thought it would take a month. He had thought it would be a form. It was not a form. It was a document of forty pages with nine appendices, and the appendices were the work: the protocol, the consent form, the assent form for those who were still under eighteen. The questionnaire, the sampling plan, the data management plan, the risk assessment, the compensation schedule, and a page about what would be done with the results.

The committee met once a month and had nine members. Two were clinicians, two were basic scientists, one was a lawyer, one was a lay member from the community, one was a statistician, and two were the chairs.

The first submission came back in six weeks with fourteen comments.

He read them in the corridor outside the office and then went in and sat down and read them again. The first comment was about re-contact. How would he find people who had moved? What would he do if a participant had died and the family answered the phone? What if the participant did not want to be found, and the family told him where they were?

The second comment was about the bone measurements. The portable X-ray fluorescence device was approved for use in a hospital setting only, and the protocol had it in a courtyard.

The third comment was about the results. What would he do with a result that was alarming and could not be treated? Who would tell the participant? What would he say?

The fourth comment was one line: “The investigator is a member of this cohort. Please address the conflict of interest.”

He wrote an answer to that one of two pages. He wrote that he had disclosed it, that the committee could require an independent monitor, that he would not interview his own family. That the row he believed to be his would be handled by a second reader. He wrote that he did not know whether the row was his and would not know until the logbook was opened. And that he had decided not to ask to see it until the protocol was approved.

The committee wrote back: “Please add an independent monitor.”

He added one. It was a retired paediatrician from the hospital who had never been to the town and did not want to go. And who read every protocol document twice and telephoned him at nine in the evening to ask what he would do if a young man with a high result asked him. Directly, whether he was going to die of it.

He wrote that answer in the third revision. It was four pages long. The paediatrician read it and said it was honest, which he took to be approval. And then the paediatrician said that honesty was not the same as a protocol, and made him write the protocol.

In the spring of the second year she gave him the files.

It was not the logbook. It was a spreadsheet, one hundred and sixty-five rows, with the columns she had built over fifteen years: subject number, sex, age, village, 2004 blood lead. 2005 blood lead where there was one, 2006 where there was one, address in 2004, guardian’s name, guardian’s phone, notes.

He opened it on his laptop in the office and scrolled through it slowly with her sitting across the desk.

“Some of the addresses are wrong now,” she said. “There is a new road where two of the lanes were the school moved in 2012. Two of the villages were renumbered in the land survey.”

He said he would start with the phone numbers.

“Half the numbers are dead. The parents have died or changed their phones. Some of the children have their own numbers now, but we do not have those numbers, because the children were four years old in 2004.”

He asked how she had traced people before.

“By the school, and by the temple, and by the lane.” She turned her mug around. “It is not a method. It is a town. You ask one person and they ask another person, and by the end of the week the person who has been in Shenzhen for eight years has heard that someone is looking for them.”

He said that his mother could ask.

She looked at him.

“Your mother is one of the best routes into the third village,” she said. “She has been at that stall for thirty years. She knows every mother in the round.” A pause. “But if she asks, the town will know in a week that the study is running, and the study is running before the committee has approved it. That is why we do not ask until the letter comes.”

The letter came on the first of March, in the second year of the pandemic, and it was two pages and the second page was the conditions.

He read it standing in the corridor. Then he sat down on the bench by the water dispenser and read it again.

Approved. Valid from the first of March. Twenty-four months of fieldwork, extendable.

He took the bus home that afternoon with the letter in his bag. The bus was half empty because of the pandemic and everyone wore a mask, and the fields went past the window and the fish ponds between them. The ponds held the sky and gave it back, and the light was the flat white light of March.

His father was in the hospital. He had been in for eleven days with a lung infection on top of everything else, and the doctors had said what the doctors said. And his mother had not told him until the fourth day because she did not want to disturb the ethics application.

The lane in March of that year was quiet in a way it had never been quiet.

The stall was open but there were three tables instead of five, because two had been taken away in the first year of the pandemic and never brought back. The chai poh stall was shut. The water man had sold the tricycle and now worked in a warehouse in Chaoyang town and came home at weekends.

The courtyards were empty. Not closed—empty. The doors stood open and the rooms inside had nothing in them but a bench and some empty sacks and, in one of them, a child’s bicycle upside down with its chain off.

The park’s gate still had a man and a book. There were four lorries in the yard and a queue of six people and the queue was patient.

His mother’s tray work had changed. The trays came from the park now, not from the lanes. She signed for them at the gate and brought them home and sorted them and carried them back. The sorting was the same. The chips were smaller. She said the chips were smaller now because everything was smaller now.

He went to the hospital first and stood at the window of the ward with his mask on and looked at his father. Who was asleep with a tube in his nose and the sheet pulled up to his chest, and the hands on the sheet were still orange at the second knuckle.

Then he went home and put the letter in the drawer, on top of the letters from Siam. And went out to the stall and ordered a bowl and ate it standing in the lane with the roar long gone and the bread of the morning cold in his hand.

The ward held six beds and the window looked at a wall with a pipe on it. The man in the next bed had his family around him. They talked in a dialect he did not know, ate oranges, and put the peel in a plastic bag.

His father slept with his mouth open and the tube taped to his cheek. The machine beside the bed made a sound like a slow wave, up and down, and the numbers on it were green.

The nurse came in at four and checked the line and wrote on a chart and said he could stay ten minutes.

He asked her what the numbers were.

She said the saturation and the rate and the pressure, and she said them the way a person says the names of streets.

He asked what the plan was.

She said the doctor would come in the morning.

Then he heard his own voice come out of him at a volume he had never used in a hospital, saying that the doctor had come in the morning for eleven days, and that the sheet under his father had not been changed since Tuesday, and that he had been at a window in this corridor for two hours and nobody had asked him who he was.

The ward went quiet. The family around the next bed stopped eating. The nurse looked at him with the flat courtesy of a woman who has heard this before, from better men, on worse days, and said she would fetch the sister.

He sat down. His hands were shaking and he put them under his thighs.

Outside, the pipe on the wall ran from one side of the window to the other and did not do anything visible, and he looked at it until the shaking stopped.

At six his father woke and looked at him and said, “The letter.”

He said the letter had come.

His father nodded and closed his eyes and said, “Good. Then the fees are not wasted.”

That was all. He did not ask about the method or the committee or the twenty years. He asked about the fees.

That night his mother sat at the table with the letter in front of her and read it twice.

“So it begins,” she said.

“It begins.”

“Twenty years late.”

“Twenty years late.”

She nodded the way she nodded at a good weight on the scale. Then she said the thing that he had been waiting for and had not known he was waiting for.

“I will start with the third village,” she said. “The mothers will talk to me. They will not talk to a doctor from Shantou with a clipboard.”

He said the committee had conditions.

“The committee is in Shantou,” she said. “The mothers are in the lane. You write the form. I will pour the tea.”

# PART THREE — THE CINNABAR