Chapter 17
The Mob
The Society had a name by then, and a charter, and a membership of about four hundred, and it had been born out of a spreadsheet about the monk and had grown, in less than a year, into the thing the couplet had warned about.
They called themselves the 山城济公互助会 — the Mountain City Ji Gong Mutual Aid Society — and their charter, which I read in full once, was a good charter. It said that members would help the elderly cross the city’s stairs; that they would mediate debts between neighbours before the collectors came; that they would escort women home at night; that they would never carry weapons; that they would report crimes to the police; that they would never imitate the fall of the founder, which was their phrase for the drunk act, and which was, by then, the only part of the founder they had any interest in avoiding. The charter’s first principle was a line from the couplet’s first half: the Buddha stays in the heart. The charter’s last principle, added later, was a line the founder had never said: help is not a performance. They meant it. That is the thing I need the reader to hold. Four hundred people in a city of thirty million, most of them sincere, most of them lonely, most of them poor, had built a mutual-aid network out of a drunk’s accident, and for the first year it did real good, and the good did not make it safe, because a good movement with a bad aim is more dangerous than a bad man with a knife.
The aim changed after the trial.
I cannot prove who aimed it. I have my beliefs. What I can prove is the sequence. The son testified and was believed. The fire expert testified and the arson count began to tremble. The city’s feed, which had spent a year in love with the drunk, began to spend, in the way that feeds do, its equal and opposite week: the vigilantes were the problem, the fan caused the boy’s death, the drunk should have let the law handle it, where was the drunk when the temple burned. And into that week came the Society, and into the Society came a man named Lai San.
Lai San had been in the franchise business since the spring. He had a warehouse office, a merchandise line, a blessing livestream, and a “legal aid” service that helped creditors find debtors. And when the trial turned the city’s mood, he did the thing that a franchise does when the market shifts: he rebranded. The “legal aid” closed. The merchandise went quiet. And the Society’s four hundred sincere members, who had been a mutual-aid network, found themselves with a new leadership, a new slogan — 守住我们的巷子 , hold our alleys — and a new activity: the citizens’ mediation. They would go, in groups, to the offices of the collection companies, and they would stand outside with banners, and they would ask the collectors to come out and mediate their debts, and the collectors would stay inside and call the police, and the police would come and tell the group to disperse, and the group would disperse, and the next week they would go to another office, and the videos would go out, and the videos did numbers.
For three weeks nothing happened. And then, on a Thursday in the tenth month, at a collection office in Yubei with a reception desk and a young woman who said good morning to the debtors, the mediation did not disperse.
I was not there. Huajiao was not there. Yaoji monitored it, because Yaoji monitored everything, and he called me at eight in the evening and said, in the flat voice he used when he was reading something he did not want to read, “Put on the radio. It’s at the office. There’s a crowd. Someone had a knife.”
The clip, when it came out, was four minutes and forty seconds long, and it was shot from the window of a building across the street. In the first minute, about sixty people with banners stand outside the office. In the second minute, the office door opens and a man comes out — not a collector, a security guard, an old man of about sixty in a grey uniform with a radio on his chest — and he stands in the doorway and says something the audio does not catch, and the crowd moves toward him, and he puts his hands up. In the third minute, someone in the crowd — I still do not know who; the identity was never established; the file says only a member of the crowd — pushes the guard, and the guard falls against the door frame and hits his head, and the crowd, which had a charter, and which had a first principle about the heart, and which had never once intended to hurt the old man in the grey uniform, surges forward; and in the fourth minute, the old man is on the ground and the crowd is around him and someone is calling an ambulance and someone else is filming and the guard does not get up.
He had a wife and a daughter in a vocational school and a bad knee. He had taken the security job at sixty-one because his pension was not enough and the office was air-conditioned. He died in the hospital eleven days later, of a head injury he got on the ground, in a doorway, in a surge, at a mediation he had not been part of and had not been told was coming.
The Society’s leadership, within a day, had a statement. The statement said that the Society was a peaceful organization, that the incident was the fault of an unaffiliated individual, that the Society mourned the guard, that the Society would cooperate with the investigation, and that the real violence in this city was the collection industry. The statement was true. Every clause was true. And beneath it, in the comments, in their thousands, the city did the thing the city does, which is to find a face for a tragedy that has no face, and the face it found was mine.
This is what the drunk started.
He made the fan and the fan made the crowd.
Where was the drunk while the old man was dying.
He was in a courtroom being honest. That’s what he does. He’s honest while other people pay.
And then, in the middle of it, the Society put up a post about Aguang.
They used his sister. That is the part I cannot forgive, and I do not know who to be unforgiving toward, because it was not one person; it was a mechanism. Someone in the Society’s media team had found the sister’s account, the one she had made to say RIP 阿光. he tried to help. he was nineteen, and they had made a memorial video out of it — the boy’s cardboard fan, the night market, the eighty phones, the founder’s silence — and the video’s title was 谁杀了阿光 , who killed Aguang, and the video’s answer, which it never said out loud, was: the man in the yellow jacket. Not with a knife. With a story. And the story had been the Society’s, and the Society did not see the contradiction, because a movement never sees the contradiction; the movement sees only the wound.
The sister — Amei, fifteen, the girl with the concrete life and the favorite noodle order for a dead brother — did not give them permission. I know this because Yingtao found out, and because Yingtao went to her, and because the girl told Yingtao that the Society’s people had come to her school gate and put a phone in her hand and asked her to say her brother’s name, and she had said it, because she was fifteen and they were adults and they said it would help, and then the video had gone everywhere, and now her brother was a martyr with a hashtag, and she could not get him back.
That was the week the archive was attacked.
It happened on a Saturday, at the print shop in Shapingba, and it happened in the way the city does a thing it intends to be deniable, which is to say it happened with four people and no weapons and no words.
Yingtao was at the desk with the window blacked out and the kettle on and the wall of hard drives behind her. Four people came up the stair in the afternoon — two men and two women, in ordinary clothes, in their twenties, with the flat cheerful faces of people who had spent the day in a group chat. They did not say anything. They walked into the room and began taking things off the wall. They took the drives, one by one, and put them in a bag. They took the monitor and the keyboard. One of the women picked up the gimbal, looked at it, and put it back, and then took it. And when Yingtao stood up and said, “That is evidence in a trial,” the woman looked at her with what Yingtao described to me later as the worst face she had ever seen, which was not a cruel face but an unbearably certain face, the face of a person who believes they are doing the right thing, and said:
“You are not the archive. The archive is the city. You are the woman who kept it from the city.”
Then they went down the stair. They did not touch Yingtao. They did not have to. They took the drives, which held four thousand entries, the spine of a year and a half of work, and the four hundred aunties and riders and witnesses and bystanders who had trusted the archive, and they walked out into the city with it in two plastic bags, and the police were called and came, and the statement was taken, and the drive recovery was attempted, and everything that could be restored was restored, and everything that could not was gone, and I have never known how much was gone, because Yingtao never told me, because Yingtao stopped telling anyone anything for a while after that, which was the most frightening thing that happened to her in the whole of the two years, and which I have not yet forgiven the city for.
She did not cry. That is what I remember. She stood in the stripped room with the kettle boiling and the blacked-out window and the wall where the drives had been, and she looked at the shapes the dust had left on the plaster, and she said one sentence, and then she did not speak for three days.
“The camera is the only institution that cannot be bought,” she said. “I forgot that it can be stolen.”
I found Lai San that night, at the warehouse office, and I want to write this next part carefully, because in the version of the story the city tells, I go there and I beat him, and in the version the Society tells, I go there and I threaten him, and neither happened.
I went there with Huajiao, because she refused to let me go alone, and because she had, by then, a specific and terrifying skill at reading whether a man was going to be violent, and she said on the way, “He’s not the aim. He’s a channel. If you hit him, the channel becomes a martyr.” We stood in the loading bay and we waited for him to come out, and when he did, in a good jacket and a gold chain, he looked at me and did not pretend not to know why I was there. He had, I noticed, a copy of the fan in his own hand — the good copy, the Guangdong one, mended with the machine stitch.
“I didn’t send them,” he said. “Before you say it. The Society has a media team and a discipline committee and about four hundred people who believe things, and I am not the head of it. I am the business. I sell the robes and I run the blessing streams and I pay for the banners, and the people who took your friend’s drives are not my employees, they are volunteers. You cannot fire a volunteer. You cannot even find one to fire.” He spread his hands. “I am sorry about the drives. That is real. I am not a total fool. The archive was the only clean thing in this city and it existed because of the man in the yellow jacket, and if the man in the yellow jacket had taken my franchise offer in the spring, none of this would have happened, because I would have owned it, and I would have protected it, because I protect my assets.”
“You’d have monetized it.”
“I’d have monetized it, and it would still exist, which is more than you can say for it tonight.” He looked at me with the cheerful hopeless face. “You keep thinking there is a villain. There is no villain. There is a market, and the market moved, and the movement moved with it, and the drives went with the movement, and tomorrow the whole city will forget the drives because something else will happen. That is what you never understood, in the whole of your year. You keep looking for the man behind the curtain. There is no curtain. There is a weather system, and it rains on whoever is standing outside.”
He got into a car and drove away, and Huajiao and I stood in the loading bay, and she looked at the copy of the fan in his hand — the one he had taken with him, the one he kept, the one he had as a product — and she said, quietly, to no one, “He’s not wrong. That’s the worst part.”
That was the seventeenth week of the trial. The guard died eleven days after the surge, which put his death in the eighteenth week, three days before the closing arguments. And on the morning of the closing arguments, the city, which had been holding the guard’s death and Aguang’s video and the drunk’s honesty and the son’s tears all in the same hand, went to the polls of its own attention and decided, by a margin I could measure only in the disappearance of my own face from the platforms, that it had seen enough, and that it was time for the law to do what the law does.
I did not know then that the law would do it. I only knew that the fog had come down, and that the aunties had stopped putting the clips on the phone, and that in the stripped room above the print shop a woman was standing in front of a wall of dust-shapes where a year and a half had been, and that somewhere in the city a fifteen-year-old girl had a dead brother and a hashtag she had not asked for and a favorite noodle order that nobody was going to make.