WHERE THE WATER WANTED TO GO
☰

Chapter 33

Hangzhou, January 2023

The price war began in the first week of January, when the market’s largest foreign maker cut and everyone else answered within the month. Our order book — the intake numbers I had quoted to the board in November — became a fiction between one Wednesday and the next: cancellations do not come as letters, they come as a ratio, and the ratio moved every day in one direction.

I ran the cancellation list myself that January, the way I ran everything then — by hand, late, with the desk lamp angled onto the columns — and the list had a texture you could feel: the fleet buyers first, in blocks, their cancellations arriving with account managers attached, each one apologetic and already employed by somebody else; then the private deposits, in ones and twos, in the flat grammar of the reason fields. What the ratio did not show, and what I saw in the names, was the geography of belief: the buyers from the first season — the ones who had put money in before there was a catalog — cancelled last, and when they cancelled they used the same phrase, four of them in the same week, which I have never been able to read without hearing it: we believed you would deliver.

The refund desk learned a new job in those months: returning belief. A cancellation arrived as a form — three fields and a checkbox that admitted, in the user interface of my own company, that the vehicle might never exist — and behind each form was somebody who had run the arithmetic I had asked them to run and had decided the arithmetic no longer held. The amounts were small and the process was clean, and the refund procedures Xu Heng had forced into being in the first bad year — a fortnight’s turnaround, no questions outside the published terms — meant most of them were back in their accounts inside the fortnight. I read a sample of the reason fields the way I read warranty claims. Nobody swore. They wrote things like: I have changed my plans, or the money is needed at home. One of them wrote: please tell me the line is still running.

By spring the dealers of half the industry were advertising below the price we had costed at. I have never said, and will not say here, that this was the weather only. The weather was real: the cut, the lithium roll-off, the old guard’s inventory. But a careful man in a careful company can drown in ordinary weather, and I was busy blaming the barometer.