Interlude 30
The Feeds
A curated list of the city’s first-week coverage of the judgment. Ten entries. No two agree on what happened, what it meant, or who was on trial. Reproduced as found. The list was compiled by an account that no longer exists.
1. @CityNewsLive · 4.1M views · edited official summary > The First Intermediate Court today delivered judgment in the Hongfa Group case. The organization was convicted of the charges of organizing a mafia-like criminal organization, fraud, extortion, and unlawful business operations. The dissolved estate was held liable in the civil aspect. Sentences ranged from three years to life. The court found insufficient evidence to establish the arson count beyond reasonable doubt and acquitted the relevant defendants on that charge. The judgment may be appealed.
2. @AuntieZhangDaily · 900k views · 40 seconds · vertical > [An elderly woman, filmed at a courthouse gate, speaking into the camera while a younger woman holds a phone.] What did they say? I don’t understand what they said. I heard the fire and I heard acquitted and I don’t know which one is the thing. Somebody tell me if the temple is avenged. Nobody tells the old people anything. > ↳ @A Netizen the temple is not avenged. > ↳ @A Netizen nothing is avenged. that’s not what courts do. > ↳ @AuntieZhangDaily then what are they for.
3. @LegalXiaoWu · 1.2M views · analysis · 6 min > The fascinating thing here is not the verdict. It is the architecture. The estate was held liable, which means the dead man’s name is on the fire forever, in the civil register. But the natural persons charged with the arson were acquitted, which means no living person goes to prison for the fire. This is not a loophole. This is how organizations are designed to die: the name takes the crime, the people take the severance.
4. @ShanchengPositiveEnergy · 2.8M views · 12 seconds · slowed clip of the courthouse steps, piano > 一个城市的良心终于落地了。A city’s conscience finally lands. > ↳ @A Netizen whose conscience > ↳ @Account the city’s > ↳ @A Netizen the city doesn’t have one. it has weather.
5. @FogWalks_Archive (mirror account, unverified) · 3,000 views · no caption · one photograph > [A courthouse corridor, empty, at dawn. A chair. A gourd on the chair. Nothing else. No text. 4 likes.] > ↳ @A Netizen is this the archive > ↳ @A Netizen the archive is in a hundred places. this is one of them.
6. @XiaoMaitreya_Official · 11M views · the son’s statement > [Tan Xiao, in a charcoal suit, no tie, at a plain desk, looking directly into the lens for the first 40 seconds without speaking. Then:] Today the law did its work, and I will do mine. I will not appeal. I will not comment on the findings. I will only say this: the name that did these things is my name, and I am going to spend the rest of my life making it mean something else. If you see me fail, tell me. I will not delete the comment. > ↳ @A Netizen 格局 > ↳ @A Netizen this man is the future of this city > ↳ @A Netizen his father burned a temple > ↳ @A Netizen his father did. he didn’t. that’s the whole point. > ↳ @A Netizen is it
7. @NightMarketUncle · 260k views · 22 seconds · phone on a counter > [A noodle-stall counter, late. The vendor, an old man, is not looking at the camera. Off-screen a customer asks him what he thinks about the verdict. He does not stop working.] I think a boy died at my stall. I think the man who made the fan that the boy copied is a better man than me. I think the son is building a hospital. I think I have to sell noodles. Pick one. They all fit. [He slides the bowl across.] Next.
8. @JusticeWatchCN · 780k views · thread · 9 posts > Post 4: The verdict does not mention the security guard who died at the “mediation.” Post 5: The verdict does not mention the imitator who was killed at the night market. Post 7: The verdict does not mention the boy who drowned at the foundation-sponsored festival. Post 9: A court tries a case. A city tries a decade. The judgment is a document. The decade is still going. > ↳ @A Netizen this is the only thread worth reading > ↳ @A Netizen “the decade is still going” is going to live in my head
9. @MountainCityNights · 40k views · 8 seconds · Trail at dawn > [Fog. A ridge. An old stone step. A pair of shoes, black, new, placed neatly at the edge of the frame, as if someone had left them. No person. No caption. 2.1k comments, almost all of them a single character or a single word.]
↳ @A Netizen whose shoes ↳ @A Netizen they’re not his. he still has his. ↳ @A Netizen how do you know ↳ @A Netizen nobody ever knows. that’s the whole city.
10. @Anonymous · 7 views · a text post > i was in the courtroom. i am not going to say which day or which case or who i am. i am going to say one thing. when they read the acquittal on the fire, the man in the wheelchair did not move. and the man in the yellow jacket did not move either. and the son, who was not on trial, cried. and i thought: the father got the fire in the register and the son got the tears and the monk got nothing and the cook got nothing and the guard got nothing and the boy got nothing. and that is what a verdict is. it is a receipt. it says what was paid. it does not say what was owed.
— end of list. the compiled dataset was taken down on the ninth day. it was re-uploaded, in pieces, in eleven other places, and is still falling. of the ten entries, three are gone entirely. the shoe post has eleven million views. the tenth post, with seven views, is the one that the archive kept.