Interlude 30
The Fifty Videos
After the gala, a compilation circulated under the title “Fifty Angles on the Fall.” It was assembled by an anonymous editor and hosted on three platforms within eleven hours of the event. The list below reproduces the compilation’s own timestamps and its own one-line descriptions. The editor’s note claims the fifty were chosen from 1,847 uploads. No two descriptions of the final seconds agree. The compilation was never monetised, and the editor was never identified.
22:41:02— camera high on the east mezzanine; the atrium floor is a gold coin around a hole.22:41:04— a phone on the floor, filming the ceiling; the LED walls are playing the ledgers.22:41:06— a woman in the crowd is covering her child’s eyes and watching through her fingers.22:41:09— the drone show is spelling fu (福), the character for fortune, badly, in the smoke.22:41:11— a bought monk at the altar stops mid-blessing and does not move again for four minutes.22:41:14— the catering riders are filmed from behind; four yellow jackets at the service door.22:41:16— a child asks his mother why the picture on the wall is a bad picture.22:41:19— someone spills hotpot oil; the film on the marble catches the gold light.22:41:21— a security guard’s radio, held up close, is unintelligible.22:41:24— the crowd at the north escalator is not running; it is not yet running.22:41:27— a man films the screen and weeps and does not know why he is weeping.22:41:29— the broadcast camera swings and shows a monk’s robe on the mezzanine rail, and for one second the whole country is looking at an empty robe.22:41:31— a phone films another phone; the ledgers reflected in the small dark glass.22:41:34— a woman shouts a name that is not Tan Hong’s; nobody answers.22:41:36— the fog machine is still running; the atrium is becoming the river.22:41:38— the drone show fails; the drones hang, then fall, one by one, into the gold.22:41:40— a man in a yellow jacket on the mezzanine; he is not running.22:41:42— a security camera, recovered later, shows the twelfth-floor scaffold empty.22:41:44— a girl in a school jacket crawls out of a service vent and is not seen by anyone; the vent is thirty metres from the nearest camera, and none of the fifty catches her face.22:41:46— the water-pit under the golden Buddha; the surface is filmed from above; a shape goes in.22:41:47— a phone films a phone filming; both shake.22:41:48— a woman says, “He slipped,” and is not sure.22:41:49— a man says, “He jumped,” and is sure.22:41:50— a boy says, “He was pushed,” into a friend’s ear.22:41:51— the fog swallows the twelfth floor; the description says only “white.”22:41:52— a shoe is on the golden rail, alone, in focus, for nine seconds.22:41:53— a drone operator, off-shift, films nothing useful and keeps the file anyway.22:41:54— a woman is praying to the water-pit; she is not praying to the Buddha.22:41:55— the LED walls cut to black, then to the company logo, then to black.22:41:56— a man’s hands are bleeding; he is not the man who fell.22:41:57— the smoke alarm is the only clean sound in any of the fifty.22:41:58— a phone is dropped; the last frame is a child’s shoe and a coin of gold.22:41:59— a man in a yellow jacket is on his knees at the water’s edge; he does not dive; the description does not say why.22:42:00— the description says only: he was reaching for something.22:42:01— a woman says, “He was reaching for the Buddha’s hand.”22:42:02— a man says, “There is no hand. It’s a statue.”22:42:03— a boy says, “He was reaching for his phone.”22:42:04— the fog machine stops; the twelfth floor appears; there is no one on the scaffold.22:42:05— a guard films the service corridor; two men in work clothes go past; one has a burn scar, and the other is carrying a folded robe.22:42:06— a phone films the water; the water does not show what the phone sees.22:42:07— a woman says, “He didn’t scream.”22:42:08— a man says, “He screamed the whole way.”22:42:09— a phone films an empty escalator; someone is breathing hard off-camera.22:42:10— the description says: take this one down.22:42:11— a child films the golden Buddha and nothing else, for two minutes, in silence.22:42:12— a phone in the crowd films the crowd, and the crowd is all looking up.22:42:13— a woman films her own face; she is crying; behind her the LED walls are off.22:42:14— a man films a man filming, and the two faces are the same face in different light.22:42:15— the last useful frame in the compilation shows the VIP box: a young man alone, holding a phone at his own face, and the phone’s screen is recording.22:42:16— the description for the final video is the only entry that is not a description. It says: no one got the last second. that’s not a failure. that’s the whole country.
Editor’s afterword, posted with the compilation and deleted within the day:
I have watched all 1,847 uploads. I want to record what I did not use, because the fifty are an argument, and the argument is made by what is left out.
I did not use the videos of the water-pit after the ambulances left, because there is nothing in them, and a camera pointed at nothing is the truest thing this city owns.
I did not use the forty minutes of a child who filmed the golden Buddha and nothing else. A child’s patience is not evidence, and I did not want to explain it to anyone.
I did not use the paramedic footage, because the paramedic asked me not to, and because she was the only person in any of the uploads who touched a body with a free hand.
I did not use anything from inside the VIP box. That footage exists. It belongs to the son. The son has not released it, and I am not going to release it for him.
What is left is fifty angles on a man falling. No two agree on the last second. That is not because the cameras are bad. It is because the last second of a life, like the first, belongs to the person inside it, and the city only ever gets to film the seconds on either side.
— the compilation was taken down within a day of its posting. copies circulated for a week. three of the fifty clips were eventually introduced as evidence. the court exhibit lists them by number, and the numbers are the numbers above, and the video marked 34 was played twice.