Chapter 9
The Documentary
PART TWO
The Weight
5 May — 560 g
The documentary had a budget now. That was the first problem.
Eighty thousand yuan, a crew van, a drone, a second camera, a sound kit, and a script approved by Director Sun. The script was four pages long. It had a title, The Soul of Datong, and a subtitle, A City Remembers. It had a voiceover that Xiaoyu had written in one night, and that Sun had edited in one morning, and that was now a thing neither of them entirely believed.
The city was built on coal. For a hundred years, the coal was the city. Then the coal went away. What remains is the stone, and the people who remember.
She read it into the microphone on the first day. Her voice sounded like a tourism advertisement. She read it again, lower, slower. It sounded like a tourism advertisement with a cold.
Da Yang, the cameraman, was eating sunflower seeds in the van. He had been a cameraman for the provincial station for fifteen years and had been fired for reasons he described as “politics, mostly, and a woman.” He had a hernia and a bad knee and a way of holding the camera that made it look like a part of his body.
“The old man is a natural,” he said.
“He can’t see the camera,” Xiao Wu said. Xiao Wu was twenty-three and carried the boom mic like a sword.
“That’s why he’s a natural,” Da Yang said. “He doesn’t know he’s being looked at. The rest of us know. The rest of us are always being looked at. It ruins the face.”
“He’s blind,” Xiao Wu said.
“Same thing,” Da Yang said.
They filmed Gao at the mine on the first morning.
The heritage park was still half-built. The plaza was concrete. The visitors’ center was glass. The wall was black stone. Gao walked the site with his cane. He stopped every few steps. He turned his head. He tapped the cane on the concrete.
“They poured a floor over the mine,” he said.
“Is that bad?” Da Yang said.
“It’s loud.”
“Loud?”
“The mine used to have a sound. The shaft had a sound. The wind came up it. Now there is a floor, and the floor has a different sound. It is a dead sound. Concrete is dead. The mine was alive.”
Da Yang looked at Xiao Wu. Xiao Wu shrugged.
“Can you say that again?” Da Yang said.
“I can say it as many times as you want,” Gao said. “It will be true every time.”
They found Wang Yulan’s shop on the second afternoon.
It was a narrow storefront between a pharmacy and a mobile-phone repair kiosk. The sign said WANG’S GROCERY in faded red letters. The window was full of cigarette cartons and vinegar bottles and a handwritten sign that said NO CREDIT. Inside, the air was thick with the smell of tobacco and soy sauce and old cardboard. A woman sat behind the counter with a cigarette in her hand and a television playing a costume drama on a small screen.
Wang Yulan was fifty-one. She was thin, with a face that had been pretty once and had been worn down to something sharper. She looked at Xiaoyu, then at the camera, then at Xiaoyu again.
“No,” she said.
“I haven’t asked yet.”
“No.”
Xiaoyu put a plastic bag on the counter. Three packs of cigarettes. Two bottles of Shanxi vinegar. A box of milk candy.
“I’m not buying you,” Wang Yulan said.
“I’m buying cigarettes,” Xiaoyu said. “The vinegar is for my mother. The candy is for you.”
Wang Yulan looked at the bag. She looked at the camera. She took the cigarettes out of the bag and put them in the rack behind her.
“Five minutes,” she said. “No camera.”
Xiaoyu put the camera on the counter, lens down. Da Yang went outside to smoke. Xiao Wu stood by the door with the boom mic down at his side.
“You knew my father,” Xiaoyu said.
Wang Yulan lit a cigarette. She did not offer one.
“Luo Cheng,” she said. “The singer.”
“Yes.”
“He was a good man. He sang at the mine parties. He sang ‘The Great Happiness’ at my wedding. He was drunk. He forgot the words.”
“He died in 2005.”
“Yes.”
“Were you there?”
“I was on the surface. I was pregnant. I heard the roof go. It sounded like a door closing in a very big house.”
Xiaoyu’s throat was dry. She had not expected the door.
“Did you know Ma Jun?” she said.
Wang Yulan smoked. The television costume drama went on. A woman on the screen was crying.
“Ma Jun was a good man,” Wang Yulan said. “He talked too much.”
“That’s what everyone says.”
“Because it’s true.”
“Did he talk to you?”
“He talked to everyone. That was his problem. He thought if he explained it well enough, people would do the right thing. He was wrong. People do the right thing when it is easy and the wrong thing when it is hard. Ma Jun never understood that.”
“Were you part of the group?”
Wang Yulan looked at her. The cigarette burned. The ash was long and gray.
“I kept the minutes,” she said.
“Where are they?”
“Burned.”
“Why?”
“Because I have a daughter,” Wang Yulan said. “She is a teacher. She has a daughter. I burned them the year after Ma Jun disappeared. I burned them in the stove. I watched the paper go. It took a long time. The notebook had a plastic cover.”
Xiaoyu looked at the counter. Under the register, under a stack of lottery tickets, there was a corner of something black. A notebook. It had a plastic cover.
She did not say anything.
Wang Yulan saw her look. She put her hand on the counter, over the lottery tickets, and the corner of the notebook disappeared.
“Five minutes,” she said. “Time’s up.”
Duan was at the gate on the third morning. Xiaoyu did not tell him the camera was running. She had Xiao Wu put the mic in the booth. She stood beside Duan with her hands in her pockets and asked him about the old days.
He talked about the mine. He talked about the shift changes and the canteen and the man who sold illegal lottery tickets in the changing room. He talked about the winter the pipes froze. He talked about the summer the coal gangue hill caught fire and burned for a month.
Then she asked about the group.
“Which group?”
“The reading group. The seven.”
Duan looked at the ticket booth. He looked at the buses.
“I don’t know what you’re talking about,” he said.
“Ma Jun. Wang Yulan. Old Hou. Zhao Deshun. Li Xiaobo. Gao. You.”
He was quiet for a long time. The buses came and went. A child dropped an ice-cream cone and cried.
“We all did what we had to do,” Duan said.
“What does that mean?”
“It means what it means.”
“That’s not an answer.”
“It’s the answer I have.”
He cleared his throat. He looked at her, and for a moment his face was not the face of a security supervisor. It was the face of a man who had been carrying something for a long time and had forgotten how to put it down.
“Your father was a good man,” he said. “Don’t make trouble for him.”
“He’s dead.”
“That’s what I mean.”
He walked away. Xiaoyu watched him go. Then she went into the ticket booth and took the recorder out from under the counter. The red light was still on.
Director Sun called that afternoon.
“The mayor’s office has seen the rough cut,” he said. “They like it. They want more of the old man. Less of the mine.”
“The mine is the story.”
“The mine is the past. The festival is the future. Don’t confuse them.”
“The soul of Datong is the mine.”
“The soul of Datong is what we say it is,” Sun said. “That’s what a brand is.”
Xiaoyu was quiet. She was standing in the parking lot of the scenic area, with the drone case at her feet and the cliff behind her.
“I’m not making a brand,” she said.
“You’re making a six-minute film for a festival,” Sun said. “That’s a brand.”
They filmed Gao at the old kiln on the last evening.
The kiln was a parking lot now. The asphalt was new and black. There was a white line painted down the middle. A sign said NO PARKING AFTER 8 P.M. The village had put a plastic bench at the edge of the lot, and a trash can, and a small sign that said CULTURAL HERITAGE SITE in four languages.
Gao stood in the middle of the parking lot. He had the erhu. He did not know where the kiln had been, exactly. He turned around twice. Then he stopped.
“Here,” he said. “It was here.”
The camera was on a tripod. The sun was going down. The sky was the color of weak tea. Da Yang said, “Whenever you’re ready.”
Gao played “Seven Lamps.”
The sound was huge. It was too big for the parking lot. It went out across the asphalt and into the village and came back off the houses. The low register was a room. The high register was a wire. The tune counted down. Seven. Six. Five. Four. Three. Two. One.
Da Yang lowered the camera. Xiao Wu took off his headphones. The village was quiet. A dog barked, once, and then stopped.
“What the hell is in that thing?” Da Yang said.
“An erhu,” Xiaoyu said.
She knew it was a lie. She did not know why she told it.
That night she listened to the audio.
She had recorded the kiln on the boom mic and on the camera’s internal mic. She imported both tracks. The boom track was clean. The camera track was dirty, full of wind and a car and a dog. She soloed the boom.
The song was there. Under the song was the hum. Stronger than it had been in March. Not the wind. Not the microphone. In the instrument. A low steady note, below the tune, below the breath, a note with a grain in it, like a voice held under water.
She put on headphones. She closed her eyes. She listened.
It sounded like a second person in the room.
She took the headphones off. The room was silent. The refrigerator hummed. A car went by. She put the headphones back on.
The hum was still there.